Announcement
We're back! Ovens are hot and the pies are flying!
Will you do us a favor? Bypass the ASAP option for carryout and use the drop down to select a specific pick up time--this is a huge help to us and ensures your pies will be hot and ready at pick up. THANKS!
Menu Icon Legend

House Pies

These are our NY style hand tossed round pies with specialty toppings. Choose a medium 12 inch or a large 16 inch. Sorry, no substitutions on our house pies.
L--Pepperoni Gem 
An award winning pie from a master, Tony Gemignani. Pepperoni, creamy ricotta, our own hot honey and fresh organic basil
$27.00+
M--Pepperoni Gem 
An award winning pie from a master, Tony Gemignani. Pepperoni, creamy ricotta, our own hot honey and fresh organic basil.
$17.00+
L-- Sausage, Onion, Gouda 
NY sauce, both mozarella and smokey gouda, onion and sausage.
$26.00+
M-- Sausage, Onion, Gouda 
NY sauce, both mozarella and smokey gouda, red onion and hand pinched sausage. A prefect trupple!
$16.00+
L--Brooklyn  
Hand pinched sausage, pepperoni, mozzarella, red onion, roasted red pepper sauce & oregano and topped with fresh grated parmasen after cutting.
$27.00+
M-- Brooklyn 
Hand pinched sausage, pepperoni, mozzarella, red onion, roasted red pepper sauce & oregano and topped with fresh parmesan after cutting.
$16.00+
L-- Central Park 
Fresh spinach, roasted tomatoes, artichokes, and feta. Light, flavorful, fresh and so pretty!
$26.00+
M--Central Park 
Fresh spinach, roasted tomatoes, artichokes, and feta. Light, flavorful, fresh and so pretty!
$16.00+
L- Red Top 
This no cheese pie is an East Coast classic! Just our NY style sauce with slivers of garlic, EVO then topped with crispy focaccia bread crumbs.
$25.00
M- Red Top 
This no cheese pie is an East Coast classic! Just our NY style sauce with slivers of garlic, EVO then topped with crispy focaccia bread crumbs.
$15.00
L-Barn Burner 
A new pie with onion, roasted garlic, pickled jalapeno and bacon and a touch of cream.
$26.00+
M- Barn Burner 
A new pie with onion, roasted garlic, pickled jalapeno and bacon and a touch of cream.
$16.00+
L-- Fancy Cheese 
NY sauce, mozzarella and roasted tomato. Out of the oven we dress the pie with fresh basil and balsalmic reduction.
$26.00+
M-- Fancy Cheese  
NY sauce, mozzarella and roasted tomato. Out of the oven we dress the pie with fresh basil and balsalmic reduction.
$16.00+
L-- Hang 10 
Roasted pineapple, our mild red pepper sauce and bunches of pepperoni. Add fresh pickled jalapeno and or Mike's Hot Honey for some heat!
$28.00+
M-- Hang 10 
Roasted pineapple, our mild red pepper sauce and bunches of pepperoni. A swirl of Mike's Hot Honey brings a touch of sweet heat!
$17.00+
L-- Marg 
Per customer request--Our NY Style pie, with classically Margherita toppings--hand crushed tomato, fresh mozzarella, garlic olive oil and fresh basil. Add some extras if you like!
$26.00+
M--Marg 
Hand crushed tomato sauce with velvety fresh mozzarella, garlic olive oil and fresh basil. Add some extras if you like!
$16.00+
L-- Fats 
Its back with an updated price. Same heavy portions of sausage, pepperoni, red onions, and smoked bacon all gooey and melted into mozzarella. Enjoy!
$28.00+
M-- Fats 
Sausage, pepperoni, red onions, and smoked bacon all gooey and melted into mozzarella. Enjoy!
$17.00+
L--Supreme 
Sausage, pepperoni, mushroom, onion and green olive for a combo pie that checks all the boxes!
$28.00+
M--Supreme 
Sausage, pepperoni, mushroom, onion and green olive for a combo pie that checks all the boxes!
$18.00+
L--Spinaci 
A 3 cheese spinach pie with a touch of roasted red pepper, finished with dollops of ricotta and fresh grated parmesan.
$26.00
M--Spinaci 
A 3 cheese spinach pie with a touch of roasted red pepper, finished with dollops of ricotta and fresh grated parmesan.
$16.00

Build Your Own

That tender fold-able NY Style pie with YOUR favorite toppings, priced individually. All pies include cheese.
Large BYO 
16" pie feeds 3-4 adults. It's our tender fold-able crust with homemade sauce and real mozzarella. Add your favorite toppings, priced individually.
$18.00+
Medium BYO 
12 inch pie feeds 2 adults. Its our tender fold-able crust with homemade sauce and real mozzarella. Add your favorite toppings, priced individually.
$13.00+

Sicilians

This square pie feeds a crowd! Our focaccia style pie is 14" x14" light and tender with a cripy crust. Cheese hides UNDER the sauce for Sicilian's. BYO or select a House Classic. Hey, do you need it with dairy free Vegan Shred? Order a day ahead and we can do that!
House Sicilian 
Our GIANT focaccia style square pie in all your favorite combonations! A light crispy crust that feeds a crowd!
$0.00+
BYO Sicilian 
Our GIANT square pie with your favorite toppings! Light airy cold fermented crust, crispy bottom and feeds a crowd!
$27.00+

Sides

Salads, Garlic Knots, Focaccia and more!
Arugula Salad 
Organic arugula with roasted grapes, goat cheese, and toasted almonds. Homemade lemon dressing on the side.
$10.00+
Sunflower Ranch 
Spring greens, carrot, cucumber, homemade buttermilk ranch dressing and our own Sunflower Crunch.
$10.00+
Garlic Knot 
8 warm fresh knots tossed in garlic and parmesan, served with a side of sauce. Yes, please!
$9.00
Bacon Gouda Focaccia 
A winter winner! Great tonight or tomorrow morning with eggs!
$5.49

Specials!

Deals and fun pies. All 12 inch mediums.
Cousin Vinny 
A classic pepperoni and green olive add a drizzle of garlic sauce and finish with fresh ground black pepper.
$15.00
Cheese Special 
$10!! Our medium 12" classic New York Style--dough, sauce and cheese.
$10.00
Medium w/ 1 Topping  
Any 1 topping for $12!
$12.00
Pepperoni, Feta and Basil 
From one of our regular customers! We love this simple elevating combonation! 12" pie.
$15.00
T Shirt 
New shop T's! Available in slate gray or white, Medium thru 2XL. Universal sizing, 100% cotton.
$12.99
Med DutchTown 
A white pie with smokey Gouda, mozzarella, caraway infused sauerkraut, keilbasa and green onion!
$15.00

Cauliflower Crusts

This 10 inch pie serves one. It's made with cauliflower, egg white, tapioca starch and Parmesan. Choose a Build Your Own or make it one of our specialty pies. Not all our specialty pies work well on this crust. If you don't see it listed, we don't offer it.
BYO Cauliflower Crust 
Build your cauliflower crust pie. This small pie serves 1 and performs best with light toppings. We start with cheese. Add up to 3 toppings. Extra cheese doesn't work well here.
$16.00
Specialty Cauliflower Crust  
A cauliflower based crust with eggwhite, and cheese. A few of our house specialty pies work well with this crust. Check them out here. Not all specialty pies are available on a cauliflower crust.
$16.00

Side Sauce

Homemade Ranch, Hot Honey or our own NY style pizza sauce. All great for dipping!
House Ranch 
Our Homemade Ranch-- a creamy buttermilk ranch with a little Herby kick.
$0.99
Hot Honey 
Our own infused Hot Honey.
$0.99
Pizza Sauce 
Our own classic NY Style sauce.
$0.99
Garlic Sauce  
A classic dip anything pizza.
$0.99
Balsamic Glaze 
Sweet with a little tang.
$0.99
Hot Pepper Flakes 
Add some heat! Absolutely. And they are FREE.
$0.00

Desserts

Our new 5 year anniversary Tiramisu is here! 3 layers of espresso soaked ladyfingers, mascarpone, cream and cocoa.
Cannoli  
New Oreo Cookie edges! Three small crispy cannoli shells filled with traditional chocolate chip creme and OREO cookie edges!
$6.00

Drinks

Jarrito's fruity sodas, water and sparkling water.
Jarritos 
The fruity and delicous Mexican soda with flavors like Mango, Fruit Punch, Pineapple, Mandarin and the best selling--Grapefruit! Yep, thats right, Grapefruit!
$3.00
Water 
$1.15
San Pellegrino 
The Italian sparkling classic
$3.25
Your cart is empty.
Loading, please wait.